Only 3 months after 9/11, Bin Laden could have been caught dead or alive

“Failure to attack when he was holed up in Tora Bora has had far-reaching effects”

As Barack Obama prepares to increase troops in Afghanistan, the US Senate has released a report saying the Americans missed the golden chance to attack al-Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden and his deputies when they were holed up in the mountainous area of eastern Afghanistan three months after the 9/11 twin tower attacks.

Al Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden

The Senate report categorically states that Bin Laden was unquestionably in Tora Bora when the United States should have mounted a swift assault.

Review of existing literature, unclassified government records and interviews with central participants “removes any lingering doubts and makes it clear that Osama bin Laden was within our grasp,” says the report.

On or about 16 Dec.2001, Bin Laden and his deputies, however, “walked unmolested out of Tora Bora and disappeared into Pakistan’s unregulated tribal area,” where he is still believed to be based, it says, asserting that the failure to kill or capture Bin Laden has had lasting consequences beyond the fate of one man. The al-Qaeda leader’s escape laid the foundation for today’s reinvigourated Afghan insurgency and inflamed the internal strife now endangering Pakistan.

“Removing the al-Qaeda leader from the battlefield eight years ago would not have eliminated the worldwide extremist threat,” the report says. “But the decisions that opened the door for his escape to Pakistan allowed Bin Laden to emerge as a potent symbolic figure who continues to attract a steady flow of money and inspire fanatics worldwide. The failure to finish the job represents a lost opportunity that forever altered the course of the conflict in Afghanistan and the future of international terrorism.”

The report by the Committee on Foreign Relations is part of US Senate’s continuing examination of the conflict in Afghanistan.

“When we went to war less than a month after the attacks of Sept.11, the objective was to destroy Al Qaeda and kill or capture its leader, Osama bin Laden, and other senior figures in the terrorist group and the Taliban, which had hosted them. Today, more than eight years later, we find ourselves fighting an increasingly lethal insurgency in Afghanistan and neighbouring Pakistan that is led by many of those same extremists. Our inability to finish the job in late 2001 has contributed to a conflict today that endangers not just our troops and those of our allies, but the stability of a volatile and vital region,” says Committee Chairman John F. Kerry.

Read the full report here or the excerpt below:

_____________________________________________

EXCERPT: Bin Laden expected to die. His last will and testament, written on December 14, reflected his fatalism. But the Al Qaeda leader would live to fight another day. Fewer than 100 American commandos were on the scene with their Afghan allies and calls for reinforcements to launch an assault were rejected. Requests were also turned down for US troops to block the mountain paths leading to sanctuary a few miles away in Pakistan. On or around December 16, two days after writing his will, bin Laden and an entourage of bodyguards walked unmolested out of Tora Bora and disappeared into Pakistan’s unregulated tribal area. Most analysts say he is still there today. For American taxpayers, the financial costs of the conflict have been staggering. The first eight years cost an estimated $243 billion and about $70 billion has been appropriated for the current fiscal year—a figure that does not include any increase in troops. But the highest price is being paid on a daily basis in Afghanistan and Pakistan, where 68,000 American troops and hundreds of US civilians are engaged in the ninth year of a protracted conflict and the Afghan people endure a third decade of violence. So far, about 950 US troops and nearly 600 allied soldiers have lost their lives in Operation Enduring Freedom, a conflict in which the outcome remains in grave doubt in large part because the extremists behind the violence were not eliminated in 2001.

2nd Anniversary of Blogging

It’s the second anniversary of my blog Greater Voice. It started on 26 November, 2007 and is growing slowly and gradually since then. Thank you very much for all love, blessings and support. Click for 1st Anniversary of Blogging.

The story that night would have been different

I wrote this book not only as a wife who lost her husband but also as an educated person who needed to throw light on the lapses in our system

26/11 martyr Ashok Kamte’s widow Vinita has painstakingly chronicled the events leading to her valiant husband’s death in last year’s Mumbai terror attacks, thoroughly conducting her own probe.

Her book To The Last Bullet released Wednesday at Mumbai’s Taj Mahal Palace and Tower hotel, which itself was one of the sites of the terror attacks, undoubtedly slams the police and is sure to embarrass the government.

Till date, Vinita maintains that her husband Kamte did not get any help for about 40 minutes after being shot by the terrorists. Additional police commissioner Ashok Kamte was killed with two other top officers Hemant Karkare and Vijay Salaskar in the attacks.

Vinita Kamte

“If only help had arrived earlier, the three officers including my husband could have been saved,” she said at the book launch. “I wanted to put his life and sacrifice in a proper perspective it deserves. It was not easy to take this decision because it was a question of whether I should speak out against a force which my husband was a part of and throwing light on the shortcomings of what happened during 26/11.”

Vinita, 43, used information from right to information requests, meetings with eyewitnesses, police control room records and post mortem reports.

I join Vinita and her two sons in mourning the death of the man who indeed died a hero’s death that night.

US court sends man to 14 yrs in prison for mosque firebomb

“Every Muslim who saw news photos with Swastika painted on the burned out Islamic center was victimized by the attack”

While the ghosts of Babri Mosque are returning to haunt Indian politics 17 years after a mad frenzy destroyed face of its secular republic, a US court has sentenced a man to over 14 years in prison for burning a mosque in Central Tennessee.

Senior District Judge Robert L. Echols of the Middle District of Tennessee Monday sentenced 24-year-old Michael Corey Golden to 14 years and three months in prison and three years of supervised released for vandalizing and burning down the Islamic Center of Columbia, Tenn.

Golden pleaded guilty on Nov.3, 2008, to destruction of religious property and to using fire to commit a felony.

He previously admitted to the court that he constructed Molotov cocktail explosive devices, ignited them and used them to destroy the mosque on Feb.9, 2008. He further admitted that while he burned down the mosque, a co-defendant painted swastikas and the phrase “White Power” on the building’s walls.

The other two defendants, Jonathan Edward Stone and Eric Ian Baker, previously pleaded guilty and are scheduled to be sentenced next month.

“The right to worship without fear of this kind of violent interference is among our most fundamental civil rights,” said Thomas E. Perez, Assistant Attorney General for the Civil Rights Division. “We will aggressively prosecute anyone who seeks to intimidate or injure any congregation because of what they believe, how they worship or who they are.”

US Attorney Edward M. Yarbrough said: “This type of crime strikes at the heart of our civil rights and religious freedoms in America. I am very pleased that through local, state and federal cooperation all defendants responsible for this vile attack have been brought to justice.”

“Every Muslim who saw the news photos with the Swastika painted on the burned out Islamic center was victimized by this attack. Today, they can clearly see that American law enforcement stands strongly with them to guarantee their freedoms to worship and assemble,” said Nashville Field Division Special Agent in Charge James M. Cavanaugh.

The Federal Bureau of Investigation, which investigated the case, said the agency remains committed to protecting the civil rights of all people through the enforcement of federal civil rights statutes. “The destruction of any place of worship will not be ignored and the FBI will make every effort to bring those who commit such heinous acts to justice.”

It’s official: Clinton fancies Miliband

He’s so vibrant, attractive … He’s so young!

Hillary Clinton’s new job isn’t all work and no play

Hillary owned up to an unlikely crush on Miliband.

Foreign Ministers Hillary Clinton and David Miliband now seem to have taken each other far too seriously, with a mutual gushing appraisal of each other.

Hillary, the 62-year-old US Secretary of State, is stated to have lavished high praise on her UK counterpart Miliband (44), during an interview with Vogue magazine, describing him as “vibrant and attractive”.

When the interviewer erred on the side of  journalistic objectivity and described Britain’s Foreign Secretary as “tall and dashing”, Clinton found it hard to control and responded: “Well, if you saw him it would be a BIG crush. I mean, he is so vibrant, vital, attractive, smart. He’s really a good guy. And he’s so young!”

Describing Miliband as smitten too, Vogue quoted him as returning the compliment, saying Clinton was “delightful to deal with”.

A good picture is worth a thousand words.

“She applies intellect but also psychology to the dossiers that she’s studying. She’s delightful to deal with one on one. She’s someone who laughs and can tease, and she’s got perspective as well,” Miliband said.

The two leaders have met several times and Clinton’s first visit to the UK in her new role in February had seen much being made in the British media of the fact she referred to the ‘special relationship’ between Britain and the US.

Speaking to Sky News at the time, Miliband had said she “couldn’t have been warmer” and praised Clinton’s “remarkable record”.

Transparency Names & Shames Nations

Afghanistan & Iraq, which receive billions of dollars in aid, are among most corrupt nations

India is ranked 84th among the 180 countries which Transparency International assessed this year for integrity.

India shares the spot with El Salvador, Guatemala, Panama and Thailand.

While Bhutan is rated as the least corrupt country in the South Asian region in the graft watchdog’s annual Corruption Perceptions Index, China, which was ranked a joint 72nd with India in 2007, is shown to have improved its corruption perception. It is now ranked 79th.

The report, released worldwide today, observed that no region remained immune to the perils of corruption. It put New Zealand, DenmarkSingapore, Sweden and Switzerland in the top five places as the least corrupt nations of the world, while at the bottom of the table come Somalia and Afghanistan.

“At a time when massive stimulus packages, fast-track disbursements of public funds and attempts to secure peace are being implemented around the world, it is essential to identify where corruption blocks good governance and accountability, in order to break its corrosive cycle,” said Huguette Labelle, Chair of Transparency International.

Fragile, unstable states that are scarred by war and ongoing conflict linger at the bottom of the index. These are Somalia, Afghanistan, Myanmar and Sudan tied with Iraq.

“Stemming corruption requires strong oversight by parliaments, a well performing judiciary, independent and properly resourced audit and anti-corruption agencies, vigorous law enforcement, transparency in public budgets, revenue and aid flows, as well as space for independent media and a vibrant civil society,” said Labelle.

He appealed to the nations that corrupt money must not find safe haven anywhere: “It is time to put an end to excuses.”

Manu’s Law

Delhi Nightlife

The convicted killer was recently found partying at Delhi’s trendy nightspots after he was released from prison, on parole

Manu Sharma is back in prison, believably having completed all the three tasks – grandmother’s religious rites, looking after the ageing mother and attending to his business – for which he was taken out of Indian capital’s high-security jail by his powerful parents.

Watching these developments with amused interest, now I feel for Manu’s fellow jail inmates who are not equally fortunate to have as powerful parents to manage their extended holidaying paroles through sheer kindness from the government, to immunize themselves against law.

Delhi Nightlife 2And had it not been the irresponsible bar brawl, guns wouldn’t have been out against the playboy son of the influential parents, who had also neutralized the media against reporting about their worthless lad coming out of jail on parole way back in September.

Their might and authority had even drawn the otherwise clean Indian Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh to an election campaign in their stronghold recently.

Manu’s powerful parents were, therefore, rightfully eager to see their jailed son among themselves, caress him, love him, console him, cheer him and take him to religious places to bring peace to the family.

But little did the brat realise that out on parole, he actually subjected his parents, once again, to degrading and humiliating situations.

His parents had not gifted him the parole for re-attempting Delhi’s night life, being well aware that their son was jailed for his acts on a hot Delhi night-party.

Manu Sharma

Manu Sharma

Jessica Lall

Jessica Lall

They had been a concerned lot, about their son Siddharth Vashisht, a.k.a. Manu Sharma, after reports of his motiveless killing of a celebrity barmaid Jessica Lall at a crowded socialite party in 1999. Thereafter, Manu’s father Venod Sharma, a wealthy and influential Congressman from Haryana, had to bear most of the brunts until the Sharma family’s ordeal got over early 2006 when it was held by a Delhi city court that Manu was not the killer. However, the celebrations were short-lived as a higher court, in a prosecution appeal, found Manu’s acquittal faulty in law, after going through voluminous record and hearing Manu’s high-profile counsel Ram Jethmalani. (read High Court judgment here)

Manu was then sentenced to life imprisonment in December 2006 and it came to be believed that rich and powerful are actually not above law.

This belief stands shaken, today. In fact, it has been broken.

Together with this, the belief of Manu’s parents in him has also been shattered. They have lost their dear son, again. Now, they’ll need to visit the prison to touch him, feel him, love him.

All this while, while the ritualistic media has been stoning the Satan, castigating indefensible Delhi Chief Minister Sheila Dixit and seeking explanations from the red-faced Lt. Governor Tejendra Khanna, I, throughout, have been feeling much for Manu’s poor parents. Manu let them down.

Their wealth and power today wear a stoic silence to Manu’s law, which the 32-yr-old tried to enforce once again at a Delhi night.

Manu proved to be a dangerous man. He shamelessly tried to relive what happened 10 years ago at the Tamarind.

Delhi’s night life seduced him enough to an exclusive club-bar which even the son of Delhi Police Commissioner finds hard to resist.

Manu’s parents have become poorer. Their son will have to complete the rest of his life term in jail, unless he succeeds at the Supreme Court.

Until then, the nights at Delhi’s exclusive clubs and bars shall go on, without Manu, of course.

CIA rewarding ISI with huge money

Is this why militants are targetting ISI these days?

CIACIA is paying hundreds of millions of dollars to ISI since the 9/11 attacks on the twin towers, accounting for as much as one-third of the US spy agency’s annual budget.

This huge money is being funneled to the Pakistan’s intelligence service for operations as well as rewards for the capture or death of terrorist suspects, Los Angeles Times reported.

The newspaper quoted officials as saying that though there have always been fears of corruption, it is money well-spent.

There are also long-standing suspicions that the ISI continues to help Taliban extremists who undermine US efforts in Afghanistan and provide sanctuary to Al Qaeda members in Pakistan.

But US officials have continued the funding because the ISI’s assistance is considered crucial.

An official was quoted as saying that despite deep misgivings about the ISI, “there was no other game in town.”

Sept 11 twin towersThe payments to Pakistan are authorized under a covert programme initially approved by then-President Bush and continued under President Obama but the extent of the financial underpinnings have never been publicly disclosed. Officials said the CIA has also routinely brought ISI operatives to a secret training facility in North Carolina, US.

The CIA depends on Pakistan’s cooperation to carry out missile strikes by Predator drones that have killed dozens of suspected extremists in Pakistani border areas.

On Friday, militants hit ISI’s regional headquarters in Peshawar in an attack that killed at least 10 people. In May, a similar strike near an ISI facility in Lahore killed more than two dozen people.

________________________________________________________

ISI’s role in the past as a supporter of militancy is no secret, but now the tables have turned. The ISI is therefore pitted against the militants and vice versa. The security and law enforcement agencies are being targeted left, right and centre by the terrorists in the wake of the military offensive against the militants in Swat/Malakand and South Waziristan. The attack on GHQ last month was the most significant terrorist attack in the history of Pakistan, highlighting the fact that the militants have now declared open war against the state of Pakistan and its military and intelligence agencies. Needless to say, the intelligence agencies are playing a crucial role in the military operations against the terrorists. Without good real time intelligence, no military operation can be successful, especially when the enemy is engaged in guerrilla and asymmetrical warfare.” – An editorial in Pakistan’s Daily Times, Nov. 15, 2009, Safety No More

Pak Docs Killed My Wife: Wasim Akram

Wasim and Huma AkramCricket legend Wasim Akram has taken up his wife Huma’s death with Pakistan government which has ordered a three-member committee to investigate the medical care provided to her in Lahore.

Akram was neither happy nor satisfied with the attention provided to his wife by Pakistani doctors. Huma, 42, died at the Apollo Hospital in Chennai (India) on October 25 where she got admitted after developing complications in an air ambulance on her way to Singapore from Lahore.

Pakistan Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani has directed top federal health officials to investigate the causes of Huma Akram’s death, the Dawn newspaper reported.

“Wasim Akram has approached the prime minister and requested the government to help and investigate the circumstances which led to his wife’s death,” a top official of the federal government was quoted.

Huma Akram's burialOn the former captain’s complaint to the federal government and on the directives of the premier, the federal health ministry has formed a three-member committee comprising top medical professionals who will probe the causes of Huma Akram’s death. The federal health investigators have also been provided with a detailed eight-page medical report of the late Huma. The report also carries a death certificate issued by the Apollo Hospital along with Huma’s medical history. The enquiry team is expected to submit its findings within 10 days.

Pink Cricket Ball Trials In IPL-3

pink ball

White balls could be under threat.

White cricket balls, notoriously difficult at times for both batsmen and fielders, could soon be replaced by pink balls across the one-day international format and the trials will happen at Indian Premier League beginning March 12 next year.

A consensus is being arrived to phase out the white balls which, after being discoloured by the grass, are difficult for fielders and batsmen to see in certain light conditions.

“Pink ball trials will happen at IPL practice games,” IPL chairman and commissioner Lalit Modi told Greater Voice. Modi appears enthusiastic for pink balls which could also show up better on television.

Sources said the trials are going to happen with the aim of a pink ball being used in one-day internationals as the pink balls would compensate for visibility difficulties.

Traditionally, white balls are used for one-day matches and red balls are used for Test and all other cricket. Pink balls have already been used in selected cricket matches in England as experiments to see if they are more visible to players and fans.

Marylebone Cricket Club, which creates and upholds the rules of cricket, has also worked with scientists at Imperial College in London to determine the merits of a fluorescent pink ball.

“This is very interesting. After trying white and orange, a colour might have been found that is easier on the eye,” said senior photographer Partha Sarkar, an expert in covering cricket.

Barack Kumar Bahadur Obama

bahadur obamaOne year ago, Barack Obama was elected as the US President on a message most succinctly defined by a single word: ‘change’.

However, there has been a mixed scorecard on ‘change’, especially on changing the ways of the Bush era.

But, at the same time, though Obama might not have achieved anything for the US or the World, he’s already got Nobel.

May be  a Nepali blogger at mero-bichaar.blogspot.com understands the ‘change’ Obama meant. Hence this pic on Barack Obama’s One-Year Anniversary. Click here for the earlier post on Obama.

Assets of Supreme Court Judges

I appeal to the youth of Kashmir to join in building a new Kashmir: PM

The following is the text of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s speech at the inauguration of the historic Anantnag-Qazigund rail link in the Kashmir Valley Wednesday:

‘I am delighted to be back in the valley of Kashmir in the lovely season of autumn. We will soon see the beautiful golden hues of the season and the magnificent chinar will soon be flaming red.

I have come today to inaugurate the Qazigund-Anantnag rail link. I congratulate the Indian Railways and the people of Kashmir for this achievement. The day is not far when trains will run from Jammu to Srinagar through the Banihal Pass.

The last time I came to Jammu and Kashmir, the State assembly elections were going to be held. Later, the Lok Sabha elections were also held. I am happy that the people of Jammu and Kashmir turned out to vote in these elections in large numbers. I believe that it was a vote for a peaceful path to a better tomorrow. I applaud the wisdom and good faith of the common man of Kashmir. The elected government has a golden opportunity to consolidate the peace in the State.

In the last five years, the government of India has taken a number of steps to bring development to Jammu and Kashmir. We have tried to revive the traditional connectivity between the people of the region. We took the bold step of reviving the movement of goods and people across the Line of Control on the Srinagar – Muzaffarabad road and on the Poonch – Rawalakot road. I am happy to announce that the central government has decided to fund the additional cost of Rs. 385 crore to build the heritage Mughal Road that will connect Shopian with remote areas of Poonch and Rajouri.

Unprecedented resources have been committed to the State for its comprehensive reconstruction. But I recognize that the benefits are trickling down slowly. This state of affairs should change. We have to speed up the pace of development in the state. We have to reverse the brain drain that has denuded the state of many of its teachers, doctors, engineers and intellectuals. We have to create the conditions for them to return and to be the instruments of change and development. We want to strengthen the hands of the State Govt. so that they can implement an ambitious development agenda.

I would also urge that the time has come for elections to local bodies be held quickly. This will increase the people’s participation in the processes of development.

I appeal to the youth of Kashmir to join in building a new Kashmir. I understand their frustration. But things are changing. I urge them to think constructively about how to build their futures.

The Central Government will make all efforts to involve the youth of the State in constructive work. Under the ‘Skill Development to Employment’ Programme, the Ministry of Tourism will train 300 youths of the State. In addition, 200 youths will be trained and deployed as tourist escorts during the Amarnath and Vaishno Devi Yatras. The Ministry of Labour will train 8000 youths in the ITIs every year.

As part of the national programme the Ministry of Youth Affairs will deploy around 8,000 youth in Jammu and Kashmir on a voluntary basis. They will engage in public service such as cleaning of the Dal lake.

I believe that the IT Sector in JandK can be as developed as in other states of the country. We will fully support the efforts of the State in this area. I am happy that more than 600 youth of the State trained under a Central Government project have been employed in the IT sector recently.

I am happy to announce that the Government of India has decided to set up two Central Universities in JandK, one in Jammu and one in Kashmir.

The majesty and splendour of this beautiful valley and the culture of hospitality of the Kashmiri people are second to none. Its magnificent lakes and forests have charmed travelers for centuries. It offers the solemnity of the Buddhist monasteries of Ladakh, the treasures of the Hazratbal shrine and the piety of the Raghunath temple. Let us build Kashmir into one of the world’s top tourist destinations.

The picturesque Dal Lake is the icon of the tourism industry in Kashmir. We have been funding a project for the conservation of the lake but progress has been slow. I would urge the State Government to set up a task force to expedite the project. The Centre has decided to commit additional funds of Rs. 356 cr for this project. We will also discuss with the State Government how to expedite ongoing projects for the conservation of Wullar Lake and Manser Lake.

The Government is concerned about reports of receding glaciers. I am happy to announce the launch of the National Mission on Sustaining the Himalayan Eco-system. We wish to preserve the sacred heritage of places like the Amarnath shrine.

The era of violence and terrorism is coming to an end. The public sentiment is for peace and for a peaceful resolution of all problems.

When I came to office in 2004, I had said that our Government is committed to having unconditional dialogue with whoever abjures violence. We had discussions with different groups. We had a number of round table conferences. All issues were discussed. We tried to give voice to the demands of all sections of the people. We have implemented a number of initiatives as a result of this process.

I wish to say again today that we are willing to talk to anyone who has any meaningful ideas for promoting peace and development in Kashmir. We want to carry all sections of the people with us in resolving the political and economic problems of Jammu and Kashmir.

I had also said that I was ready to discuss all issues with Pakistan. I did so not because of weakness but from a position of strength. We had the most fruitful and productive discussions ever with the Government of Pakistan during the period 2004-07 when militancy and violence began to decline. Intensive discussions were held on all issues including on a permanent resolution of the issue of Jammu and Kashmir.

For the first time in 60 years, people were able to travel by road across the LoC. Divided families were re-united at the border. Trade between the two sides of Kashmir began. In fact, our overall trade with Pakistan increased three times during 2004-07. The number of visas that we issued to Pakistanis doubled during the same period. An additional rail link was re-established.

These are not small achievements given the history of our troubled relationship with Pakistan. Inside the valley, as militancy declined, trade, business and tourism began to pick up. We were moving in the right direction. For the first time there was a feeling among the people that a durable and final peace was around the corner.

However, all the progress that we achieved has been repeatedly thwarted by acts of terrorism. The terrorists want permanent enmity to prevail between the two countries. The terrorists have misused the name of a peaceful and benevolent religion. Their philosophy of hate has no place here. It is totally contrary to our centuries old tradition of tolerance and harmony among faiths.

I strongly believe that the majority of people in Pakistan seek good neighbourly and cooperative relations between India and Pakistan. They seek a permanent peace. This is our view as well.

The cross-LoC initiatives have been well received on both sides of the border. But I am also aware that they are not as people friendly as they could be. Trade facilities at the border are inadequate. There are no banking channels. Customs facilities need to be strengthened. There are no trade fairs. The lists of tradable commodities need to be increased. Clearances for travel take time. Prisoners of India and Pakistan are languishing in each other’s jails even after completing their sentences.

The fact is that these are humanitarian issues whose resolution requires the cooperation of Pakistan. We are ready to discuss these and other issues with the government of Pakistan. I hope that as a result things will be made easier for our traders, divided families, prisoners and travellers. For a productive dialogue it is essential that terrorism must be brought under control.

We will press the government of Pakistan to curb the activities of those elements that are engaging in terrorism in India. If they are non-state actors, it is the solemn duty of the government of Pakistan to bring them to book, to destroy their camps and to eliminate their infrastructure. The perpetrators of the acts of terror must pay the heaviest penalty for their barbaric crimes against humanity.

It is a misplaced idea that one can reach a compromise with the ideology of the terrorists or that they can be used for one’s own political purpose. Eventually they turn against you and bring only death and destruction. The real face of the terrorists is clear for the people of Pakistan to see with their own eyes.

I hope that the government of Pakistan will take the ongoing actions against the terrorist groups to their logical conclusion. They should destroy these groups wherever they are operating and for whatever misguided purpose.

I call upon the people and government of Pakistan to show their sincerity and good faith. As I have said many times before, we will not be found wanting in our response. In the words of the poet:

‘There are moments in history when wrong decisions are taken; the effects of which are felt for ages’

I appeal to the Government of Pakistan that the hand of friendship that we have extended should be carried forward. This is in the interest of people of India and Pakistan.

In conclusion, I wish to convey my good wishes to the people of Jammu and Kashmir. I hope that the future will bring a new era of peace, reconciliation and development.’

Happy Diwali

diwaliThe Festival of Lights – Diwali – has always meant CELEBRATIONS – rows of lighted lamps and colourful bulbs, bursting of crackers, new clothes, exchanging gifts, festive meals, cleaning home thoroughly and opening doors and windows to welcome the Goddess of Wealth Mother Lakshmi.

Today is Diwali. This day, I encourage you to remove anger, hate, and jealousy from your lives. Let’s see the good in others, including enemies.

As I light lamp at my home, I wish you all a Happy Diwali.

Oooooooooooobama

A 48-year-old ambitious boy from Honolulu getting Nobel Peace Prize 2009 was a big big NEWS, announced while the recipient was fast asleep. Who doesn’t know it’s still a surprise for the US President Barack Obama  himself!

May be, everyone responded to the 2009 announcement from the Nobel Committee. But, cartoonists world over got a new job – to paint the most powerful president red. What do you say about this?

obama nobel cartoon

Vanity Fair on Mumbai Terror – There’s Twist

mumbai terrorHere’s an interesting twist.

NDTV’s Barkha Dutt got Vanity Fair to update their website, presumably because the story portrays her in poor light.

But since the first vanity fair  article was sent as an email attachment (as opposed to a link), journalists were able to compare the updated text with the original text:

Before -

barkha dutt“We are all locked in Chambers—200 of us.” That exaggerated number was quickly passed to Indian TV. “There are reports of hundreds locked in Chambers,” Barkha Dutt announced. Within moments, handlers watching in Pakistan appeared to have alerted the terrorists, and a hail of bullets was fired at Chambers.

After -

“We are all locked in Chambers—200 of us.” That exaggerated number was quickly passed to Indian TV and announced on air. Within moments, handlers watching in Pakistan appeared to have alerted the terrorists, and a hail of bullets was fired at Chambers.

Austerity – Jai Ho!

“Sonia Gandhi flies economy class to Mumbai with security staff.” Doesn’t this reduce austerity to absurdity?

This is nothing but The Great Austerity Tamasha. And did you hear airlines upgrading ordinary citizens to accomodate VIPs in economy class? What’s this?

Wouldn’t then it be fun if the Congress President now issues a diktat instructing her partymen to demand 25% less bribes as an austerity measure!

Austerity is, after all, great. And someone rightly commented – “What’s this austerity? Coz you need money to keep some people poor!”

By the way, Minister Shashi Tharoor had a 5 star hotel lunch October 3rd with the media telling them why he has now chosen a life of austerity.

OoooooooH.

Lata Mangeshkar

lataLata Mangeshkar turns 80 on Monday, September 28.

I’ll be listening to Lata Hits, and there are so so many, during my travel during Dussehra festivals.

What’s your favourite song of hers? Think hard.

Hitler AIDS Moment

Is it fair to warn people of AIDS by likening the deadly disease to Adolf Hitler, Saddam Hussein or Joseph Stalin? 

An advertising agency had done that.

Its 45-second ad on German TV and also in cinemas shows a couple having sex and as the commercial progresses, the man’s face turns into Hitler’s as he looks straight into the camera. The tagline being: “AIDS is a Mass Murderer. Protect Yourself!”. hitlerHitler may be the ugliest face you can use to show evil but you cannot make a point like this – that AIDS, like Hitler, is a mass murderer. Oh! C’mon.

The advertisement’s shock value is hard-hitting and is sure to generate controversy, particularly when it fails to provide any kind of actual prevention message.

This ad campaign has been designed by Regenbogen e.V. in conjunction with the advertising agency ‘das comitee’.

“Our campaign to mark World AIDS Day 2009 speaks in clear terms: the new slogan is ‘AIDS is a mass murderer’. The few mass murderers who have claimed a similar number of human lives are shown: Adolf Hitler, Joseph Stalin and Saddam Hussein. The campaign is designed to shake people up, to bring the topic of AIDS back to centre stage, and to reverse the trend of unprotected sexual intercourse. Because anyone can become infected,” announces the campaign office. saddam

According to the ad agency, public interest in AIDS has massively declined over the past number of years. The number of victims, however, has not.

As of now, over 28 million people worldwide have died. And every day, almost 5000 new deaths are added to that number. This makes AIDS one of the largest mass murderers of all time.

“In Germany alone, around 60,000 people are infected with HIV or AIDS. Nobody should be allowed to forget these numbers. As anyone who forgets can become a victim themselves,” it says.

The full commercial can be seen here. Warning: It has adult content. Watch AIDS is a Mass Murderer music video by clicking here.

Let Ishrat’s case be the last fake encounter, at least

Ishrat's sisters Nuzhat and Zeenat

Ishrat's sisters Nuzhat and Zeenat

I am with Ishrat’s family. You too may follow me.

Spare a moment to think about her family members who today find themselves isolated and socially ostracized for a crime their beautiful Ishrat Jahan, a 19-year-old college girl, may or may not have committed. Ishrat cannot come back now. She’s dead. She cannot tell her story. She cannot defend herself. She has been wrongly branded a terrorist, without any evidence or a trial. She was not even questioned. 

According to fellow journalist Pritish Nandy: “It’s tragic. Worse, it’s criminal. In any case, she committed no crime. She was killed by the police on the suspicion that she may commit a crime.”

Amazing!

The country just saw a storm on Sept.7, 2009 when Ahmedabad magistrate S P Tamang ruled that the incident in which Ishrat and three others were killed in June 2004 was a “fake encounter”. Tamang named top gun D G Vanzara as accused in the “cold blooded murder” of the four.

We know that Vanzara and some other policemen are already in jail in connection with the much publicized Sohrabuddin killing case, in which the Gujarat government had been asked to pay compensation by the Supreme Court.

ishrat 1Stating that Ishrat and three others were killed in a fake encounter by the police for personal interests, promotions and appreciations, Tamang appended a list of top police officers running into about two pages who he held responsible for the fake encounter. Tamang report said the police “kidnapped” Ishrat and three others from Mumbai on June 12, 2004 and brought them to Ahmedabad. The four were killed on the night of June 14 in police custody, but the police claimed that an “encounter” took place on the morning of June 15 near Kotarpur water works on the outskirts of Ahmedabad. It said the explosives, rifles, and other weapons allegedly found in their car were all “planted” by the police after the encounter.

The police had earlier claimed that Ishrat, a resident of Mumbra near Mumbai, and three others — Javed Sheikh, a convert son of Gopinath Pillai of Kerala and two Pakistani citizens Amzad Ali Rana and Jishan Jauhar — were connected with Pakistan-based terror group Lashkar-e-Taiba, and were coming to Gujarat to assassinate chief minister Narendra Modi to avenge the 2002 communal riots.

Immediately after the Tamang report, political parties jumped in slamming the Gujarat government. But Modi quickly rejected the report and on Sept.9, 2009, the Gujarat High Court stayed the controversial report.

On a visit to US, Home Minister P Chidambaram said that the Gujarat Government could not justify the killings. “Certainly no one suggested that based on an intelligence input you should kill someone. If a state government acts as though intelligence inputs are evidence or conclusive proof I am sorry for that government.”

Incidentally, the Indian government’s affidavit filed in the Gujarat High Court confirmed that Ishrat Jahan, her partner Javed Sheikh alias Pranesh Pillai and two others killed in the 2004 encounter had links with the LeT.

But the Home Minstry is now clarifying that it had just passed on to the Gujarat government the information regarding Ishrat’s association with LeT. As regards the subsequent action taken by the Gujarat police on the inputs, which were obviously not conclusive proof, the Union home secretary clarified that the Centre could in no way be held accountable for the same.

The BJP has taken strong objection to Home Minister P Chidambaram’s remarks on the encounter deaths and said the Home Minister’s remarks were uncharitable, irresponsible and politically motivated.

In view of the above facts and circumstances, it is clear that there is something annoying and frustrating about the way in which the Congress and the BJP are playing politics with the encounter that resulted in the death of 19-year-old Ishrat Jahan and three of her companions in Gujarat.

ishrat 3“The point is that we will never know whether they were terrorists. The killings made it impossible for their guilt or innocence to be established in a court of law,” wrote senior journalist Vir Sanghvi in The Hindustan Times on Sept.12, 2009. “Are we prepared to live with the situation where a policeman is prosecutor, judge and executioner?”

Sanghvi has a point.

Ishrat Jahan and three others or Sohrabuddin were not killed in cold blood in Gujarat merely because Narendra Modi is the chief minister there.

Who would dispute that over the years, our trigger-happy police have self-acquired the licence to kill virtually anybody.

Terror suspects are eliminated throughout India, with thrill and conviction. Tell me thus one thing: Does a civilized nation like ours really need encounter killings by the State?

Still, I can switch sides if anyone would tell me what was Ishrat’s plan to eliminate Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi!